Best-of lists made up 20.6% of cited pages. The matched before-and-after comparison did not show a simple naming boost.
Originally published October 7, 2026
Listicle-shaped pages represented 20.6% of distinct cited sources. The retrospective entry comparison is not placement lift.
July 9–October 6, 2026 (UTC) · 567,704 listicle-shaped pages of 2,751,223; 6,658 paired entry observations
Listicle-shaped pages made up 20.6% of distinct cited pages in our sample. They are common sources, but a citation does not guarantee that an answer names every product on the page. Our before/after analysis and other listicle studies examine different parts of that process.
The classification uses title and URL patterns across 2,751,223 distinct cited pages. It describes page shape among sources already cited, not the citation probability of a new roundup.
Average brand naming fell from 34.89% to 25.73% in the matched comparison of 6,658 page–brand pairs, spanning 945 pages and 3,774 brands.
Mean recorded seven-day rolling naming rate · % · First observed citation: June–August 2026; 14 days before and 30 days after
| Before | 34.89 |
|---|---|
| After | 25.73 |
6,658 page-brand pairs; 945 pages; 3,774 brands; brand-question combinations observed on both sides. Source: Parse index, analyzed by Signals.
First recorded citation; pages also had to appear in the later panel.
“Entry” is the first citation Parse recorded. It is not the publication date or a controlled placement intervention, so the decline does not establish that a listicle caused harm.
| Analysis | Question and population |
|---|---|
| Signals entry comparison | How did naming differ before and after first observed citation for matched page–brand pairs? |
| Peec’s listicle study | How did presence and position in repeatedly cited third-party lists relate to brand visibility? |
| Signals naming comparison | Was a brand on a cited page also named in its associated answer? |
These are different samples and outcomes, not direct replications. Do not turn either association into a promised effect of buying a higher list position.
Measured pairs whose brand appeared in the answer · % · September 7–October 6, 2026 (UTC)
| Other shapes | 39.03 |
|---|---|
| Listicle-shaped | 27.94 |
Other: 1,119,792/2,868,914; Listicle: 673,798/2,411,170. Source: Parse index, analyzed by Signals.
A separate sample of measured page-brand-answer pairs.
The naming comparison uses a separate sample: 27.94% for listicle-shaped pages and 39.03% for other shapes. A ten-product page can support an answer that selects only three. The brand-naming study explains the counting unit.
The entry-month detail below contains different groups of newly observed pages each month; it is not a single group followed over time.
Mean recorded seven-day rolling naming rate · % · First observed citation: June–August 2026; 14 days before and 30 days after
| 2026-06 | 47.63 | 30.99 |
|---|---|---|
| 2026-07 | 30.55 | 24.98 |
| 2026-08 | 25.9 | 20.93 |
2026-06: 2,278 pairs; 2026-07: 2,223 pairs; 2026-08: 2,157 pairs. Source: Parse index, analyzed by Signals.
Each month contains a different group of pages.
Inspect the comparison’s buyer, criteria and product explanation, then inspect the answer separately. A relevant passage should explain fit and a meaningful tradeoff. The best-of-list guide shows how to assess candidate pages.
Data cutoff: October 7, 2026. Answers are ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode in the stated UTC window, excluding gpt-5-mini and gpt-5-3-mini records while retaining blank model labels. Citation IDs are expanded from eligible answers. Parse and Soar source domains and subdomains are excluded. Latest content snapshots are selected strictly before October 7. Page shape uses the title/URL regex documented in SQL. The entry cohort samples up to 1,000 pages ordered by MD5 of source ID that first appeared June through August and also had citations in the later 30-day panel. Latest measured brand content is joined to daily seven-day rolling naming rates 14 days before and 30 days after first observed citation. Only brand-question combinations with observations on both sides contribute; their within-window means are averaged per page-brand pair.
Best-of lists made up 20.6% of cited pages. The matched before-and-after comparison did not show a simple naming boost.
Originally published October 7, 2026
Listicle-shaped pages represented 20.6% of distinct cited sources. The retrospective entry comparison is not placement lift.
July 9–October 6, 2026 (UTC) · 567,704 listicle-shaped pages of 2,751,223; 6,658 paired entry observations
Listicle-shaped pages made up 20.6% of distinct cited pages in our sample. They are common sources, but a citation does not guarantee that an answer names every product on the page. Our before/after analysis and other listicle studies examine different parts of that process.
The classification uses title and URL patterns across 2,751,223 distinct cited pages. It describes page shape among sources already cited, not the citation probability of a new roundup.
Average brand naming fell from 34.89% to 25.73% in the matched comparison of 6,658 page–brand pairs, spanning 945 pages and 3,774 brands.
Mean recorded seven-day rolling naming rate · % · First observed citation: June–August 2026; 14 days before and 30 days after
| Before | 34.89 |
|---|---|
| After | 25.73 |
6,658 page-brand pairs; 945 pages; 3,774 brands; brand-question combinations observed on both sides. Source: Parse index, analyzed by Signals.
First recorded citation; pages also had to appear in the later panel.
“Entry” is the first citation Parse recorded. It is not the publication date or a controlled placement intervention, so the decline does not establish that a listicle caused harm.
| Analysis | Question and population |
|---|---|
| Signals entry comparison | How did naming differ before and after first observed citation for matched page–brand pairs? |
| Peec’s listicle study | How did presence and position in repeatedly cited third-party lists relate to brand visibility? |
| Signals naming comparison | Was a brand on a cited page also named in its associated answer? |
These are different samples and outcomes, not direct replications. Do not turn either association into a promised effect of buying a higher list position.
Measured pairs whose brand appeared in the answer · % · September 7–October 6, 2026 (UTC)
| Other shapes | 39.03 |
|---|---|
| Listicle-shaped | 27.94 |
Other: 1,119,792/2,868,914; Listicle: 673,798/2,411,170. Source: Parse index, analyzed by Signals.
A separate sample of measured page-brand-answer pairs.
The naming comparison uses a separate sample: 27.94% for listicle-shaped pages and 39.03% for other shapes. A ten-product page can support an answer that selects only three. The brand-naming study explains the counting unit.
The entry-month detail below contains different groups of newly observed pages each month; it is not a single group followed over time.
Mean recorded seven-day rolling naming rate · % · First observed citation: June–August 2026; 14 days before and 30 days after
| 2026-06 | 47.63 | 30.99 |
|---|---|---|
| 2026-07 | 30.55 | 24.98 |
| 2026-08 | 25.9 | 20.93 |
2026-06: 2,278 pairs; 2026-07: 2,223 pairs; 2026-08: 2,157 pairs. Source: Parse index, analyzed by Signals.
Each month contains a different group of pages.
Inspect the comparison’s buyer, criteria and product explanation, then inspect the answer separately. A relevant passage should explain fit and a meaningful tradeoff. The best-of-list guide shows how to assess candidate pages.
Data cutoff: October 7, 2026. Answers are ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode in the stated UTC window, excluding gpt-5-mini and gpt-5-3-mini records while retaining blank model labels. Citation IDs are expanded from eligible answers. Parse and Soar source domains and subdomains are excluded. Latest content snapshots are selected strictly before October 7. Page shape uses the title/URL regex documented in SQL. The entry cohort samples up to 1,000 pages ordered by MD5 of source ID that first appeared June through August and also had citations in the later 30-day panel. Latest measured brand content is joined to daily seven-day rolling naming rates 14 days before and 30 days after first observed citation. Only brand-question combinations with observations on both sides contribute; their within-window means are averaged per page-brand pair.
Sources