The cited Reddit pages had a median thread score of 12. The study does not establish an AI-citation benefit from buying upvotes.
Originally published October 7, 2026
The median score was 12 among 11,681 measured cited Reddit pages. Order overlap and score changes are separate observations, not an AI service-effect estimate.
July 9–October 6, 2026 (UTC) · 11,681 scored cited pages; 850 normalized upvote orders; 640 normalized downvote orders
The 11,681 measured cited Reddit pages had a median thread score of 12. Modest scores were present among sources AI answers used. This sample starts with cited pages, so it cannot estimate whether adding votes increases citation probability.
Observed thread score percentiles · score points · July 9–October 6, 2026 (UTC)
| 10th percentile | 2 |
|---|---|
| Median | 12 |
| 90th percentile | 98 |
11,681 cited source pages with numeric snapshot scores. Source: Signals order ledger and Parse index.
Scores come from crawl-time snapshots. Different URLs can represent the same thread.
Scored cited pages · pages · July 9–October 6, 2026 (UTC)
| Score at most 1 | 1,106 |
|---|---|
| Score 2 to 10 | 4,185 |
| Score 11 to 100 | 5,250 |
| Score over 100 | 1,140 |
11,681 source pages. Source: Signals order ledger and Parse index.
Counts of already-cited pages; uncited threads are excluded.
A median describes the middle of this sample. It is not a minimum score to pursue or a target that makes a thread eligible for citation.
| Study | What it examines |
|---|---|
| Signals cited-thread sample | Scores on pages already observed as cited |
| Otterly’s engagement experiment | Two communities with matching posts and a combined replies/upvotes treatment |
Otterly changed comments and votes together, so its comparison cannot isolate the effect of either. Its follow-up also reports that the communities were banned. Neither design establishes a dependable benefit from purchasing votes for an ordinary thread.
The separate ledger matched 29 indexed targets among 850 normalized upvote orders and one among 640 downvote orders. Repeat orders remain separate observations, not unique threads. The limited overlap and available placement timestamps do not isolate a service effect.
Normalized orders with a target citation match · orders · Orders: December 2025–October 6, 2026; current-engine observations: May 24–October 6, 2026
| Upvote | 850 | 29 | 21 | 1 | 19 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Downvote | 640 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Upvote 850 orders/705 threads; downvote 640 orders/474 threads. Source: Signals order ledger and Parse index.
Before and after can overlap. Missing placement dates and incomplete earlier coverage limit the comparison.
Among orders with both starting and ending scores, median changes were 22.5 and -3 points. These are observed score changes, not counts of votes caused by the service.
Ending score minus starting score · score points · Ledger orders before October 7, 2026
| Upvote | 22.5 | 67.51 |
|---|---|---|
| Downvote | -3 | -0.86 |
Upvote: 374 paired scores; downvote: 418 paired scores. Source: Signals order ledger and Parse index.
Orders with paired scores form a separate subset. Other causes of score changes are not controlled.
Read the thread and comments for the use case, constraint or product fact relevant to the buyer. The comments study examines where brand names appeared; comment scores and thread scores are different measures.
The upvotes guide gives the practical buying decision.
Data cutoff: October 7, 2026. Answers are ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode in the stated UTC window, excluding gpt-5-mini and gpt-5-3-mini records while retaining blank model labels. Citation IDs are expanded from eligible answers. Parse and Soar source domains and subdomains are excluded. Latest content snapshots are selected strictly before October 7. Score pages require numeric score metadata. The ledger is read separately; URL paths are normalized to /comments/\<thread-id>/ with case normalization, ignoring query strings, suffixes and host variants. Only aggregate results are published. Ever indexed uses source first-seen before cutoff; before/after uses current-engine citation dates around vendor placement. Score changes use paired outcome scores.
The cited Reddit pages had a median thread score of 12. The study does not establish an AI-citation benefit from buying upvotes.
Originally published October 7, 2026
The median score was 12 among 11,681 measured cited Reddit pages. Order overlap and score changes are separate observations, not an AI service-effect estimate.
July 9–October 6, 2026 (UTC) · 11,681 scored cited pages; 850 normalized upvote orders; 640 normalized downvote orders
The 11,681 measured cited Reddit pages had a median thread score of 12. Modest scores were present among sources AI answers used. This sample starts with cited pages, so it cannot estimate whether adding votes increases citation probability.
Observed thread score percentiles · score points · July 9–October 6, 2026 (UTC)
| 10th percentile | 2 |
|---|---|
| Median | 12 |
| 90th percentile | 98 |
11,681 cited source pages with numeric snapshot scores. Source: Signals order ledger and Parse index.
Scores come from crawl-time snapshots. Different URLs can represent the same thread.
Scored cited pages · pages · July 9–October 6, 2026 (UTC)
| Score at most 1 | 1,106 |
|---|---|
| Score 2 to 10 | 4,185 |
| Score 11 to 100 | 5,250 |
| Score over 100 | 1,140 |
11,681 source pages. Source: Signals order ledger and Parse index.
Counts of already-cited pages; uncited threads are excluded.
A median describes the middle of this sample. It is not a minimum score to pursue or a target that makes a thread eligible for citation.
| Study | What it examines |
|---|---|
| Signals cited-thread sample | Scores on pages already observed as cited |
| Otterly’s engagement experiment | Two communities with matching posts and a combined replies/upvotes treatment |
Otterly changed comments and votes together, so its comparison cannot isolate the effect of either. Its follow-up also reports that the communities were banned. Neither design establishes a dependable benefit from purchasing votes for an ordinary thread.
The separate ledger matched 29 indexed targets among 850 normalized upvote orders and one among 640 downvote orders. Repeat orders remain separate observations, not unique threads. The limited overlap and available placement timestamps do not isolate a service effect.
Normalized orders with a target citation match · orders · Orders: December 2025–October 6, 2026; current-engine observations: May 24–October 6, 2026
| Upvote | 850 | 29 | 21 | 1 | 19 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Downvote | 640 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Upvote 850 orders/705 threads; downvote 640 orders/474 threads. Source: Signals order ledger and Parse index.
Before and after can overlap. Missing placement dates and incomplete earlier coverage limit the comparison.
Among orders with both starting and ending scores, median changes were 22.5 and -3 points. These are observed score changes, not counts of votes caused by the service.
Ending score minus starting score · score points · Ledger orders before October 7, 2026
| Upvote | 22.5 | 67.51 |
|---|---|---|
| Downvote | -3 | -0.86 |
Upvote: 374 paired scores; downvote: 418 paired scores. Source: Signals order ledger and Parse index.
Orders with paired scores form a separate subset. Other causes of score changes are not controlled.
Read the thread and comments for the use case, constraint or product fact relevant to the buyer. The comments study examines where brand names appeared; comment scores and thread scores are different measures.
The upvotes guide gives the practical buying decision.
Data cutoff: October 7, 2026. Answers are ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode in the stated UTC window, excluding gpt-5-mini and gpt-5-3-mini records while retaining blank model labels. Citation IDs are expanded from eligible answers. Parse and Soar source domains and subdomains are excluded. Latest content snapshots are selected strictly before October 7. Score pages require numeric score metadata. The ledger is read separately; URL paths are normalized to /comments/\<thread-id>/ with case normalization, ignoring query strings, suffixes and host variants. Only aggregate results are published. Ever indexed uses source first-seen before cutoff; before/after uses current-engine citation dates around vendor placement. Score changes use paired outcome scores.
Sources