Why your Reddit posts fail (and how to fix it)

You wrote good content. Posted it to the right subreddit. Waited.

Nothing. 2 upvotes. Buried in minutes.

You’re not alone. 94% of Reddit posts never make it out of /new. The algorithm is ruthless, and most people don’t understand why their posts die.

This article breaks down the 5 reasons your posts fail—and the specific fixes for each.

Reason 1: You’re Posting at the Wrong Time

The Timing Problem

Reddit’s algorithm heavily weights early engagement. A post at 3 AM gets buried before your audience wakes up. By the time they’re online, your post is already dead.

The Fix

Timing	Recommendation
Best times (US audience)	8-9 AM EST Monday-Friday
Worst times	12-6 AM EST
Weekends	Varies by subreddit (hobby subs peak Saturday AM)
Holidays	Generally avoid

Research your specific subreddit’s peak hours. Be available to respond to comments when you post.

Reason 2: No Early Momentum

The Momentum Problem

Reddit’s algorithm needs signal that your post is valuable. Without early upvotes, it assumes nobody cares.

Early Engagement	Outcome
5+ upvotes in 30 min	Stays visible, has a chance
2-3 upvotes in 30 min	Might survive, probably won’t
0-1 upvotes in 30 min	Buried, effectively dead

The Organic Fix

• Share with friends/colleagues who can engage authentically
• Cross-post to relevant communities
• Engage immediately with any comments
• Build a network of other Reddit marketers

When Organic Isn’t Enough

Sometimes good content needs a boost. Strategic early engagement from established accounts can give posts the momentum they need to reach organic audiences.

Reason 3: Your Account Lacks Credibility

The Account Problem

Reddit doesn’t trust new accounts or accounts with low karma.

Issue	Effect
New account	Many subreddits auto-filter
Low karma	Posting restrictions
No history	Algorithm deprioritizes
Suspicious patterns	Moderator scrutiny

The Fix (Slow Path)

1. Participate genuinely for weeks or months
2. Build karma through helpful comments first
3. Don’t spam links—provide value
4. Plan for 3-6 months of account building

The Fix (Faster Path)

Use established accounts with posting history and karma already built. Aged accounts have existing karma, history of normal activity, and access to karma-gated subreddits.

Reason 4: Wrong Subreddit Fit

The Fit Problem

Even great content fails in the wrong community. Each subreddit has unwritten rules.

Signs You’re in the Wrong Place

• Downvotes despite quality content
• Comments complaining about self-promotion
• Moderators removing your posts
• Silence—nobody engages

The Fix

1. Lurk before you post – Spend a week understanding the culture
2. Start smaller – Begin in smaller subreddits where standards are clearer
3. Adjust content – Match community expectations
4. Read the rules – Actually read them
5. Study success – What posts get upvoted? What format? What tone?

Reason 5: Your Content Isn’t Reddit-Native

The Content Problem

Reddit users hate marketing. They smell it instantly.

What Doesn’t Work	What Works
Corporate speak	Genuine value
Obvious self-promotion	Personal stories
Clickbait headlines	Data and insights
Traffic-driving content	Helping without asking
Anything that feels like an ad	Admitting failures

The Reddit Authenticity Test

Ask yourself: “Would I engage with this if it wasn’t my post?”

If the answer is no, rewrite it.

The Fix

1. Lead with value – Give something useful before asking
2. Use Reddit’s voice – Casual, direct, honest
3. Tell stories – “Here’s what happened when I…” not “Our solution provides…”
4. Accept criticism – Don’t get defensive
5. Be a person – Not a brand

The 5 Fixes Summary

Problem	Fix
Wrong timing	Post 8-9 AM EST on weekdays
No momentum	Build launch strategy for early engagement
Weak account	Use credible accounts with history
Wrong subreddit	Research culture before posting
Non-native content	Write for Reddit, not your blog

What Happens When It Works

When a Reddit post breaks through:

1. Early upvotes push it out of /new
2. More users see it, more organic upvotes follow
3. Comments add to engagement signals
4. The post climbs /hot rankings
5. Potentially reaches r/all or subreddit front page
6. Traffic pours to your site
7. The post continues ranking in Google for months or years

One successful Reddit post can generate more value than months of other marketing activities. That’s why it’s worth getting the strategy right.

For a complete deep-dive, read our comprehensive Reddit marketing guide or learn how the Reddit algorithm works.

Related Services

Continue Reading

• The Complete Guide to Reddit Marketing
• Reddit Algorithm Explained
• Reddit Reputation Management Guide
• How Our Services Work

---

Last updated: December 2024